Creating Regional Organizations to Support the Adoption of Sexual Offenses Acts in Africa

By: Lauren Zachry

Recent news has focused on very public and violent rapes in South Africa.  Attention has been on the need for increased protection of women.  In many cases, the first step towards this end is the introduction of laws designed to reduce sexual violence.  The second step is proper implementation of these laws.  Sexual Offenses Acts (SOA) are designed to consolidate a country’s existing sexual offense laws, sometimes by redefining crimes like rape to include marital rape, anal and oral rape, and sexual conduct with minors and other vulnerable populations.  The consolidation is meant to better protect vulnerable groups, including women, children and the mentally disabled, from becoming victims of sexual violence. The United Kingdom passed the first known SOA in 1956, and over the past 55 years many other countries have followed suit.  African countries only began discussions of SOAs at the end of the 20th century and have since passed legislation in Kenya (2006), South Africa (2007), and Sierra Leone (2012).  These laws have often taken many years to move from inception to passage.  In South Africa, even though discussions began in 1999, the SOA did not pass until 2007.  In Uganda, Parliament introduced an SOA in 2004, but the legislation has yet to be adopted.  By comparison, Sierra Leone passed its SOA after only a two-year debate.   Despite the implementation of these acts, some countries with an SOA still have high instances of sexual violence.  In January 2013, the BBC suggested that South Africans would never be shocked by rape and women were still not protected by the SOA.  One month later, the violent rape of a 17-year old girl finally pushed South Africans to recognize the extent of rape within the country and call for change.

The Caribbean may be a helpful model for regions in Africa, where a regional organization was created to increase dialogue about SOAs and other prevention policies among Caribbean nations.  One of the most difficult parts of creating new legislation is determining which issues are important and how to mitigate implementation challenges.  Often overlooked are the inherent biases, such as the patriarchal culture in South Africa.  The Caribbean is an example of how regional discussions regarding sexual violence and how a piece of model legislation can encourage countries to pass SOAs.  In the Caribbean, Trinidad and Tobago created the first SOA in the region and helped establish a regional organization to create a sample SOA for the other Caribbean countries to follow.  Regional organizations can be instrumental in shaping legislation within multiple countries. However, although model legislation encourages positive reform, countries may adopt aspects of the model that are based on cultural bias or do not meet the needs of the adopting country.  Countries who adopt a model are sometimes “sluggish” about going through a continual reform process.

In 1986, Trinidad and Tobago was the first country in the Caribbean to adopt an SOA.  As a founding member of the Caribbean Community and Common Market (CARICOM), Trinidad and Tobago played an influential role in the development of model legislation focusing on women’s rights.  Since Trinidad and Tobago founded CARICOM and had passed the only SOA in the region, the Legal Services of the Caribbean Community used Trinidad and Tobago’s SOA to create the Caribbean’s Model SOA.  Drafted in 1991, the Caribbean’s Model SOA has increased sexual violence awareness and has led to the adoption of SOAs by five Caribbean countries: Antigua and Barbuda (1995), the Bahamas (1991), Barbados (2002), the Commonwealth of Dominica (1998), and Jamaica (2009), which used the Model as guidance.  All of the SOAs contain similar structures and many of the same provisions, such as rape, incest, intercourse with a minor under 14, and a weak marital rape provision.  However, there are also subtle differences among the seven SOAs.  The Model SOA, along with Antigua and Barbuda, Trinidad and Tobago, and Jamaica have gendered definitions of rape where a perpetrator must be male, whereas the Commonwealth of Dominica, Bahamas, and Barbados have a gender neutral definition. Many of the Caribbean countries have also begun to incorporate changes in social attitudes and awareness regarding sexual health, such as AIDS and STD prevention, in their legislation.

In the 1970’s, women hosted two major events in Trinidad and Tobago: a television mini-series and a three day “Rape Seminar,” in order to raise public awareness of rape. The women’s movement and legislative updates made in other Commonwealth countries triggered the creation of the Legal Reform Commission in 1971.  The Commission took 15 years to reach its main goals of drafting and passing one large piece of legislation that covered all sexual offenses and to bring the law in Trinidad and Tobago more in line with changing societal values.

In Trinidad and Tobago, public opinion was a huge influence on the development of the SOA, from inception to passage.  The Commission released a proposed bill in 1985 and provided an opportunity for public comment on the legislation.  A debate ensued on television, in newspapers and in public forums, which focused on the criminalization of rape within marriage. After much compromise, the watered down version of the marital rape provision said that a husband could only be guilty of rape if there was a legal breakdown of the marriage.  The lack of regional discussion and support meant that Trinidad and Tobago relied exclusively on internal discussion, thereby creating legislation that reflected the patriarchal society of the era.

The Jamaican SOA adopted many provisions from the Model SOA, as well as the SOA in Trinidad and Tobago, such as a provision that allows for the prosecution of a homeowner who permits the defilement of a child on the premises.  Most of the Caribbean states have similar statutes that either require reporting of sexual offenses against minors, or prohibit the act of permitting sexual intercourse with a minor on the premises. However, the Legal Services of the Caribbean Community excluded the prohibition of sexual intercourse with a minor in private homes in the Modal SOA, even though Trinidad and Tobago’s SOA included this protection.  Since many of the countries have such provisions, it is apparent that the Trinidad and Tobago SOA, as well as other regional SOAs, have an important impact on new legislation.  Accordingly, Jamaica exemplifies that open dialogue and an active regional body can help countries learn from neighbor nations and efficiently adopt and implement SOAs.

On the other hand, wholesale adoption of a model can have a negative impact on an SOA if the country adopts the weaknesses of the model.  The SOA in Jamaica offers slightly stronger protections for wives than the Model SOA, yet the marital rape provision remains limited to cases in which the spousal relationship is in some way dissolved.  This is a relic from the outcry of men in Trinidad and Tobago in 1985.  Nevertheless, it slightly expands the marital rape provision to include husbands who knowingly transmit STDs through sexual intercourse with their wives.

Sexual violence remains prevalent in many African countries.  An SOA alone cannot stop rape, prostitution, or human trafficking, but having all sexual offenses in one act can help prosecutors and judges better protect victims of sexual violence.  The Caribbean is an example of how model legislation can help ease adoption of protective policies.  Additionally, the exchange of ideas between neighboring countries can also assist with development of new policies and implementation.  Other regions, such as Africa, the Middle East, or Central America, should consider engaging in inter-regional dialogue in order to adopt and implement a model SOA.  These discussions can also help lead to the creation of SOAs specific to each country’s needs to protect vulnerable populations within their borders.

The Record: This Week in Review

Governments and Private Sector Meet to Discuss Strategies for Combatting Transnational Organized Wildlife Crime

Over 150 governments and businesses are attending a UN-backed conference in Thailand from March 3rd to March 14th, organized under the Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species of Wild Fauna and Flora (CITES). Thus far the conference has focused on the importance of international cooperation in combating transnational organized wildlife crime.

UN and Arab League Negotiate with Syrian Rebels to Free Detained UN Peacekeepers

The UN has monitored Israeli-occupied Golan Heights since the 1974 ceasefire between Israel and Syria. UN representatives were on a “regular supply mission” in the area, when they were detained by Syrian rebels. The UN and Arab League have entered into negotiations with the rebels to free the UN representatives.

EU Fines Microsoft for Failing to Meet Previous Competition Agreement

In its settlement following a previous EU competition investigation, Microsoft agreed to promote a wider range of browsers in its operating system, rather than just Internet Explorer. While it implemented a “Browser Choice Screen” feature in accordance with the settlement in 2010, its most recent software update eliminated the feature. The UN viewed this oversight as a “serious breach” of the settlement agreement and fined Microsoft.

42,500 Nazi Ghettos and Camps from World War II Identified in Europe

The Holocaust Memorial Museum has identified and catalogued a shocking number of Nazi-run war camps, providing for deeper understanding of the magnitude of the Nazi camp network. Identifying these camps may have legal implications for survivors whose insurance claims and claims over stolen property have been denied in the past because they took place at unknown camps.

Saudi Arabia Halted Executions of Minors

Seven Saudis were convicted of armed robbery as juveniles and sentenced to death by crucifixion and firing squad. Human rights groups demanded that the executions be halted to prevent Saudi Arabia from violating the Convention of the Rights of the Child that was ratified by Saudi Arabia in 1996. On the day of the planned executions, the Saudi government announced that it would delay the executions in order to review the sentences.

Kenyatta Leading Poles in Kenyan Presidential Election

Uhuru Kenyatta, indicted by the Internation Criminal Court for crimes against humanity related to the violence that erupted in Kenya after the heavily disputed 2007 presidential elections, has a significant lead in the current elections as ballot counting is slowing down. Measures are being taken to prevent disputes over the election results from leading to violence, but controversy over 300,000 spoiled ballots may lead to questions over the legitimacy of the vote count.

Hugo Chavez Dies After Fourteen Years in Power

Chavez died after struggling with cancer for over a year. Vice President Maduro will be the acting President of Venezuela until elections are held in the next 30 days. New leadership in Venezuela may impact the political balance and economy of Latin America if the next president embodies more centrist values than the socialist, anti-imperialist Chavez.

Potential HIV Cure

A toddler in Mississippi has been “functionally cured” of HIV after antiretroviral medication was given immediately after birth. If this method proves effective after further testing, it may provide a revolutionary and cost-effective solution to managing the AIDS epidemic across the globe.

Technology and Index Tools of the International Chamber of Commerce

The International Chamber of Commerce released a new digitally interactive Model International Sale Contract, specifically adapted for transactions governed by the United Nations Convention for the International Sale of Goods, with user-friendly features such as pop-ups when parties select incompatible clauses. The International Chamber of Commerce further presented Open Markets Index findings that G20 countries still are not leading by example in their efforts to reduce trade barriers, stimulate growth, and create jobs, “achieving only average scores for openness.”

Tajikistan joins the WTO

Tajikistan joined the World Trade Organization on 2 March 2013, bringing the WTO’s total membership to 159. In negotiations, Tajikistan agreed to further liberalize its trade regime and integrate itself in the world economy.

The United Nations Conference on Trade and Development Collaboration Initiatives

UNCTAD coordinated a United Nations Inter-Agency Cluster on Trade and Productive Capacity mission to Myanmar along with the Economic and Social Commission for Asia and the Pacific, the International Trade Centre, the United Nations Industrial Development Organization, and the United Nations Development Programme, the World Bank, and the Asian Development Bank from 18-22 February. Their goals included establishing a Diagnostic Trade Integration Study and assisting Myanmar’s integration into the world trade system. In another collaboration, the UNCTAD and Eurasian Economic Commission agreed to sign a memorandum of cooperation to work together on regional integration, trade and competition policy, facilitation of customs procedures, entrepreneurship development, transport, and statistics.

Jim Yong Kim visits Brazil

World Bank Group President Jim Yong Kim visited Brazil for three days, where he praised Bahia Hospital for providing low-income families better access to healthcare, spoke about the impact of domestic violence on economic opportunities, and launched the “Knowledge and Innovation Initiative on the Reduction of Poverty” with the Ministry of Social Development, Institute of Applied Economics, and the United Nations International Policy Center on Inclusive Grown.

The Record: This Week in Review

Human Rights Watch Finds Israeli Airstrikes in Gaza Violated the Laws of War

Human Rights Watch has sent detailed information to the IDF about numerous airstrikes in Gaza that may have violated the Laws of War.  The airstrikes, at least 18 of them, were carried out during fighting in November 2012 and were the result of Human Rights investigations.  The IDF has said that it is conducting “operational debriefings” of the attacks and will have completed its investigation sometime in February.

UN Security Council Set to Approve Sending Peacekeepers to Mali

Although the Malian government has expressed concerns about the presence of UN peacekeepers in the country (it fears the strengthening of a split between northern and southern Mali) it looks as though the UN Security Council will be approving the deployment of about 6,000 peacekeepers in the coming weeks.  The move comes after French troops have already secured much of the country from Islamist rebels.  Some issues that still remain to be worked out is how this UN peacekeeping force will interact with the UN backed African military force (AFISMA) which is currently fighting alongside French troops.

ICC Orders Extradition of Libyan Spy Chief

 Abdullah al-Senussi, Gadaffi’s ex spy chief, has requested that he be tried by the International Court of Court in the Hague.  He has been denied access to his British lawyer and the ICC, along with other human rights organizations, have expressed concern about his ability to receive a fair trial in the new Libya, which suffers from a weak central government and lack of rule of law.  Libyan leaders however have a vested interest in trying Gadaffi’s family members and supporters in country in order to gain credibility among their own population.

U.N. Sanctions North Korea for Latest Nuclear Tests

Tensions mounted this week with North Korea conducting additional nuclear tests, resulting in tightened sanctions from the U.N. Security Council.  However, nuclear capability concerns are drawing attention away from human rights issues within North Korea.  Current estimations put the number of persons currently held in North Korea prison camps at 200,000, where they suffer torture, rape and slave labor.  Both the United States and Japan will support additional inquiries into human rights violations in North Korea.

Human Rights Watch Report on Yemen

The Human Rights Watch released a report titled “Unpunished Massacre – Yemen’s Failed Response to the “Friday of Dignity” Killings” calling attention to the inadequate investigation and prosecution of those responsible. The massacre resulted in the deaths of 45 protesters, including University students and children, and implicated the involvement of several government officials.

Australian’s Prisoner X

The New York Times reported further details regarding the mysterious death of Mr. Ben Zygier, an Australian citizen also known as “Prisoner X,” who was being held in an Israeli maximum security prison.  Israel’s Justice Ministry issued a statement denying any violation of Mr. Zygier’s rights during the secret imprisonment or criminal proceedings. Mr. Zygier was incarcerated in 2010 and suspected by the Australian government of spying for Israel.

Abuse of Canadian Women Exposed

Human Rights Watch has published a report exposing police abuse of indigenous women and children in Canada.  The report details police brutality, threats of arrest, and shaming.  The British Columbia legislature recently established an investigative unit to further explore “police-related incidents involving death or serious harm.”  The concern is that the majority of the abuse faced is not covered by the definition of “serious harm” and more needs to be done by the Canadian government to protect women and children.

Australia Accused of Human Rights Violations 

Australia has been accused of human rights violations involving 23 Indonesian minors.  They were incorrectly housed in adult prisons where they were sexually harassed by the prison guards.  Jailed between 2008 and 2011, they were originally smuggled into Australia and have since been returned to Indonesia.

Jamaica in Final Stages of Accepting $ 750 million IMF Loan

Jan Kees Martijn, Head of the International Monetary Fund million to Jamaica, stated it has reached a “staff-level agreement” with Jamaica on a $ 750 million loan. Jamaica, which derives most of its GDP from tourism and other services, has seen a decline in its economy over the last thirty years. This loan is intended to reduce Jamaica’s “medium-term financing needs” and to contribute to its “debt sustainability,” Martijn said, but the loan still needs to be approved by the IMF’s executive board—scheduled to be completed by the end of March.

Three International Organizations Collaborate for the First Time

The World Health Organization, the World Intellectual Property Organization, and the World Trade Organization released a book, “Promoting Access to Medical Technologies and Innovation: Intersections between Public Health, Intellectual Property and Trade,” marking the first time that these three organizations have come together to tackle some of the most pressing issues involving medicine and health. The book examines a range of issues related to these fields, uncovers powerful studies, and most notably, provides tools for future development and success of medical technologies and innovations.